Loading blog content, please wait...
Pulling the Trigger on a Build Before You Know Who Rents It Plenty of good builds get started with the unit count penciled in and the tenant left blank....
Plenty of good builds get started with the unit count penciled in and the tenant left blank. The spec home goes up because the comps looked strong. The duplex breaks ground because the lot could hold two doors.
Then the framing is done, the finishes are picked, and only then does anyone ask who, exactly, is supposed to live here.
That order is backward, and it's expensive. Not because you need a signed lease before you pour a slab, but because the renter you're actually chasing should shape the drawings long before anyone rents a single thing.
The person who rents your finished product has opinions about things you'll decide at the plan stage. Number of bedrooms. Whether there's a real second bathroom or a half.
How much the kitchen can swallow of the budget. Whether a garage matters or a short walk to a greenway matters more.
A traveling nurse working a contract near the medical corridor off 21st wants something different than a family relocating from out of state who needs a yard and a zoned elementary. One will pay for a sleek, low-maintenance two-bedroom. The other will walk past it for a third bedroom and a fenced lot.
You can't satisfy both with the same floor plan, so picking a direction early is the whole game. Build for a renter you've actually defined and the finishes, the layout, and the rent all line up. Build for "whoever shows up" and you end up over-improving for a tenant who never comes.
Comps tell you what already sold or rented. They don't tell you who's looking right now, and in Nashville the "who" shifts block by block.
A new build in East Nashville near the Five Points restaurants pulls a different renter than the same square footage out in a quieter pocket of Antioch or off Nolensville Road. Walkability, school zoning, commute to downtown, proximity to the next thing getting built nearby... all of it changes who raises their hand and what they'll pay.
So before the plans are final, you want a clear read on the actual demand in that specific submarket. Not the metro average. The two or three streets around your lot.
When you know the likely renter, a handful of real decisions get easier. These are the ones that move both your cost and your eventual rent:
Each of those is a fork in the road at the plan stage and a very costly change order once walls are up.
Building ahead of a known tenant isn't reckless on its own. Most spec and most new rental construction happens exactly this way. The risk is building ahead of a known type of tenant, because that's the part that's genuinely knowable before you commit.
The holding cost is the clock you're racing. Every month a finished unit sits empty is rent you don't bank plus a payment you still owe, and a product designed for a renter who doesn't exist in that submarket sits longer. That's the scenario worth avoiding, and it's avoidable at the drawing board.
A build matched to real local demand leases faster and closer to your projected rent. That's the quiet payoff of doing the demand work up front... not a guaranteed outcome, but a far better starting position.
This is the exact gap where development consulting lives. Before the architect finalizes anything, someone who reads the local rental market daily can tell you what renter your lot is positioned for, what that renter actually pays, and which of your plan decisions earn that rent back versus which just add cost.
It's the difference between asking "can this lot hold a duplex" and asking "should it, and who rents each side, and at what number." At arrt of Real Estate we think like investors first, which means the conversation starts with the pro forma and the submarket, not the elevation drawings.
Sometimes that conversation confirms your plan and you proceed with more confidence. Sometimes it shifts a three-bedroom to a two, or two units to three, or trims a finish budget that the rent was never going to support. Either way, you learn it while it's still a line on a plan and not a wall you're paying to move.
Define the likely renter. Confirm the demand in that specific submarket. Then shape the plan, the finishes, and the budget around that renter and the rent they realistically pay.
You still won't have a name on a lease the day you break ground, and you don't need one. You need a clear, honest picture of who this is for, built on what the market around your lot is actually telling you. Get that right and the renter tends to show up about the time the unit is ready for them.