Loading blog content, please wait...
Ask Your Agent to Pull the Comps Before You Make an Offer A price on a listing is an asking number, and it tells you what the seller hopes to get. It do...
A price on a listing is an asking number, and it tells you what the seller hopes to get. It doesn't tell you what the house is worth, and those two figures can sit pretty far apart. That gap is exactly what a comp pull closes before you write anything down.
Comps, short for comparable sales, are the recently sold homes near the one you want that look enough like it to say something about its value. Pull a handful of real ones and the asking price stops being a mystery. You suddenly know whether you're negotiating from the seller's wish or from the market's reality.
A good comp is close in the ways that move price and recent enough to still count. Same submarket, similar square footage, comparable condition, and ideally sold within the last few months.
In Nashville that neighborhood line matters more than people expect. A four-bedroom in East Nashville and a four-bedroom in Sylvan Park can carry different values even when the floor plans are nearly twins, because the buyer pool, the lot sizes, and the walkability aren't the same. Comps pulled from the wrong pocket of town will quietly lead you astray.
Beware the comp that's technically nearby but actually different. A renovated flip and a dated house two doors down are not the same product, even on the same street. The adjustments for condition, a finished basement, a newer HVAC, an extra bathroom, are where the real work lives, and it's work a sharp agent does in their head before they ever call you.
Sellers set prices for all kinds of reasons that have nothing to do with value. Some aim high to leave room. Some price under market hoping to start a bidding war.
Some had their number set months ago and the market shifted underneath them.
When you anchor your offer to the list price, you're letting the seller define the conversation. Pull the comps first and you walk in with your own number, grounded in what actual buyers actually paid for actual houses.
That shift changes how you negotiate. You're no longer arguing against the seller's opinion. You're pointing at four homes that sold and explaining what they say about this one.
Markets move in seasons, and comps have a shelf life. A sale from this past spring reflects a different pace of buyer demand than what's happening across Nashville right now in the fall of 2026, when inventory tends to sit a little longer and the frenzy cools.
Older comps can make a house look like a bargain or a stretch when the truth has moved. Your agent should weight recent sales heavier and note which ones closed before the season turned. A number that was accurate in April might be stale by October, and in a shifting market that's the difference between a clean offer and an overpay.
Days on market belong in this read too. A home that's been listed for weeks tells you something the comps alone won't, and it often means your offer can come in with more room than the listing suggests.
It can tell you where a fair offer lives, how much negotiating room you likely have, and whether you're about to overpay in a way that'll sting at resale or at appraisal. That last one is practical: if your offer runs well past the comps, the lender's appraisal may not support the price, and then you're renegotiating or covering the gap in cash.
It can't predict exactly what the house will sell for or guarantee your offer wins. Comps are a map, not a crystal ball. Another buyer with different motivations might pay more, and that's their call to make, not a sign your number was wrong.
What comps give you is a defensible position. You offered what the evidence supported, and you know the ceiling where walking away is the smart move.
Anyone can click into a listing and see three "comparable homes" the site auto-selected. Those algorithmic picks lean on bed and bath count and square footage, and they routinely miss condition, the exact street, the busy road behind the lot, and the view that adds value you can't put in a spreadsheet.
A buyer's agent who knows the submarket throws out the bad comps the software kept and finds the good ones it never surfaced. At Arrt of Real Estate, that read happens before you fall for the kitchen, because the point of representation is to hand you the real number early, while you still have room to decide with a clear head.
Ask for it plainly. "Before I make an offer, pull the comps and walk me through them." A good agent won't flinch at that, because it's the whole job.
The ones who hand you a clean comparison and tell you honestly where the price should land are the ones worth keeping your number next to, and they'll tell you to pass when the math says pass.
Make it a habit on every house you get serious about, not just the ones that feel like a stretch. The home that looks underpriced deserves the same check as the one that looks rich. Either way, you write your offer knowing what you're doing, and that confidence is worth more than any asking price ever told you.